Jump to content

bring back the old newsgroup!


Recommended Posts

i liked the old newsgroup WAY better.

 

in the old newsgroup, you were subscribed by default to all of the groups, and whenever someone posted a question, it went to everyone.

 

there was MUCH more user participation!

 

this new web-based newsgroup is a ghost town, because people dont linger around long enough to see a post they might be able to help with.

 

thanks for listening. (if anyone out there IS listening)...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eric,

 

There certainly were advantages of the old user group - most notably in the email-based nature of it and the immediate response that was given in many cases.

 

However, there were some serious disadvantages to that old system as well. Regarding the email of posts capability, we had dozens of customers contact us about, you guessed it, the flood of out of office replies. This was something the old system had no real control over. In looking at the logs from that old system, there were also a sizeable number of users who actually labeled emails from that old forum as SPAM which caused it's own set of deliverability problems.

 

Lastly, the old forum itself was based on technology that was circa 1983. Not that there was anything wrong with 1983 but web based forums such as these have been shown to be much, much more preferable here in the 21st century. The underlying technology of that old forum was dropped from being supported in the 1990's, I believe, if that's any indication of the vintage of the technology that was used.

 

For those users that would like to receive email notifications for any new activity on the forums, there's an ability to signup for notifications. An email will be sent out when there is activity in that forum with a handy link to view the full content.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eric,

 

I gave your post some additional thought and think I may have posted a reply too soon. Sorry if my first post came off a bit defensive. Maybe it's because I personally despised the old forum and was glad to see it go and maybe it's because were here in the "....rants...." forum.

 

Thinking more about your post then....

 

It sounds like the base of what you are requesting is a higher level of participation here in the community. With the instant email notification capability of the old forum, members received an email right there in their inbox and were able to reply to a post quite quickly. This responsiveness and level of activity was nice to see and it seems that there can be times here in the new user community where a post goes unanswered for some time.

 

Does that about sum it up for you?

 

If so, I think we (Printable that is) can look into strategies to increase both membership and participation in the user community. The new community is only 4 months old and we already have over 550 registered users. This is great to see but there are certainly thousands of users out there which haven't joined yet.

 

I, for one, would love to see this community as the #1 go-to place for all users with a question about the use of our products. I've talked to a number of customers over the past weeks who were actually completely unaware that the community even existed! We can obviously do some quick things to get the word out to more users.

 

As far as increasing participation, we've thought about various incentive programs designed to reward those customers who make the biggest contributions to the community - both in quantity and quality of posts. There's a couple ideas of how we can do this which I've been mulling over.

 

So please let me know what you think of this. If we look to increase membership and participation in the community, would that satisfy what you're looking for?

 

Thank you for this thought-provoking post!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Mark,

Yes ... that is what I meant. The old forum had much more user participation because of its "in-your-face" method of displaying new posts.

 

And yeah I guess you're right ... the old newsgroup is very outdated.

 

As far as incentives ... have you ever heard of the website experts-exchange.com? I have been a member of that site for a long time. Back in the day, the site worked as a barter system ... you went to that site and posted your question. You also had to assign a "point value" to your question as well. 100 points for a question that was easy or not urgent, 500 points for a question that you considered tough, or you needed an answer to it right away.

 

Literally, within minutes, you would get at least one response. You would read through all the responses, and if someone answered your question, you would award them with the points. The more points you earned (by correctly answering questions), the more questions you were allowed to ask.

 

That is a subscription-based site. Nowadays you can just pay $50 and get to ask unlimited questions.

 

I'm not sure that this model would work for the FusionPro newsgroup, but some type of 'point' system would encourage users to help answer questions. At the end of the year (or maybe every 6 months), whomever had the most amount of points per category would win some sort of prize - $50 amazon.com gift certificate, a free copy of FusionPro ... whatever.

 

And how about this ... why not bring back a little bit of functionality from the old site? 2-3 times per day, each member of the printable newsgroup would receive a 'summary' email ... basically a list of all of the questions that have been asked, answered or commented on within the last 8-12 hours. Each user could quickly skim through this summary email and if a particular question or comment caught their attention, they could click on the link which would bring them straight to the message thread in the newsgroup.

 

The user could also 'subscribe to' or 'watch' that particular thread, so that whenever another comment was posted to that thread, he/she would receive an email right away, instead of waiting another 8-12 hours for the next 'summary' email.

 

At the very LEAST, a daily summary report. I've posted questions on these newsgroups before and havent received a single answer. There may be several hundred subscribers, but i'll bet only 4 people saw my post.

 

If someone has subscribed to these newsgroups, they are most likely looking for quick answers. What you have to ask from the members in return is active participation. It should be mandatory that all users get email summaries throughout the day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Eric,

 

These are all great suggestions - thank you.

 

I like the idea of a points system with some type of reward associated to it and will look into the options for it. There are a ton of "mods" for vBulletin (the forum software we use) and I'm sure there has to be something that we can add.

 

The summary email is also a great idea. We'll take a look into options for this as well.

 

We have plans to increase membership and use of the forum throughout 2009 that are already underway. I'm confident these will bring additional members to the community as well as increase per-user participation.

 

So... more to come. Thanks again for the suggestions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I echo Eric's post.

 

I loved the daily summary e-mail. I would never forget to read my e-mail. Now there are days I go without coming to the forums. I learned so much just by reading my summary e-mails.

 

I will check out the e-mail notification Mark suggested, I just want to let Printable Eric is not alone so they can continue to improve this forum.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As Mark said, we are looking at various enhancements to this forum, including ways to allow users to more easily be notified of new posts.

 

In the meantime, you can always bookmark the "New Posts" link (at the top of each page) and check it as often as you want:

http://forums.printable.com/search.php?do=getnew

 

I usually check this a few times a day, depending on what else I'm working on and how stuck I am on it. :)

 

You could also get tricky with some HTML and code up your own page to auto-refresh the "New Posts" page. For instance, you could copy-and-paste the following into a new HTML document on your machine:

<HTML><HEAD><meta http-equiv="refresh" content="600"> 
<TITLE>Printable User Community - New Posts (Auto-Refresh)</TITLE></HEAD>
<FRAMESET ROWS="0%,100%" framespacing=0 border=0 frameborder="no">
<FRAME NAME="up" SRC=blank.html>
<FRAME NAME="down" SRC="[url]http://forums.printable.com/search.php?do=getnew[/url]">
</FRAMESET></HTML>

Save the document, then open it in your web browser. You may need to "Allow active content" or otherwise enable the meta-tags depending on your browser settings.

 

You can modify the "content" attribute on the first line to adjust the number of seconds between auto-refreshes. It's currently set to 600 seconds, or ten minutes.

 

The caveat here is that if you click on another link, say to view or reply to a thread, you'll want to open it in an new tab or window, as the auto-refresh won't stop as long as you've got the page open, and will revert back to the "New Posts" page regardless of whatever else you were doing. More sophisticated solutions are possible.

 

I've attached the sample page to this post (remove the ".txt" extension after downloading.

PrintableNewPostsAutoRefresh.html.txt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just my two cents again as well - I read every single e-mail that came through the old lists system, and while it may be older technology and many have moved to a forum based support system - I really enjoyed seeing every issue and solution. I still have months of e-mails saved and still search through it for issues. I permantley have my e-mail open, and thus would see issues as they arrive.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

this same issue is THE reason why printplanet.com has died ... it shifted from the old-style, in-your-face email subscription, to this newer web-based forum.

 

back in the day there was LOTS of participation on printplanet. and now ... well i cant even tell you when was the last time i logged on.

 

dont get me wrong ... there are DEFINITELY advantages to the web-based forum. (i gotta say the single biggest advantage is the search capability). with the old email based forum, i would frequently SAVE all of the email posts into a separate folder in my Inbox, and 6 months later if i had to search for something (like a JavaScript rule) i would search my mailbox. But the way the messages were stored (not threaded) it was a pita to search. So in this respect the web-based forum rocks.

 

but because members are not getting emails on a daily basis, the participation has died down (probably) 95%.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
I prefer this format. I use GUA forums, B4Print forums and EMC forums which all use this format. It is so much easier to search for help on a topic, and to post a topic. The old format was difficult to follow threads and it led to a lot of repeat posts, which this format cuts down on. My only complaint is that I wish they had transfered the old post data to this format, so i could find my old posts so i don't have to ask the same questions again, as I had bookmarked my old posts for quick reference.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello,

 

The process of moving the old posts from the previous forum onto this new forum is a bit complicated as it involves some low level database work (export from old - import to new). This will require our developers to get involved and is a task we will be working on as time permits given the product-related enhancements that they are currently working on.

 

Agreed - there's a ton of great info in those old posts and there's good value in getting them into this interface.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i definitely like the new web-based forums.

however, as discussed above, there needs to be a way to get more user participation. personally (i hate to say this) i never log into the forum unless i need help with something.

 

with the old newsgroup, the questions were sent to me in an email and because of that, i was very active in discussions and have surely helped plenty of people in the past.

 

but i understand printable is looking into ways to get member participation back to where it was before.

 

personally, i think it should work this way ...

EVERY message that is posted to the forum gets sent out to every member in an email (just like the old newsgroup). Each member can decide if they want these emails to come in real-time, or in a summary at a certain time of day.

 

let's face it... if you're on this forum posting a question, it's probably because you're in the middle of a fusionpro project and you need help! you can't afford to wait for someone to read your post and reply a week later.

 

and although the staff at printable are very helpful (and also very active in these newsgroups), it definitely benefits everyone when you can get help and/or feedback from other fusionpro users.

 

and maybe ... as i mentioned in a previous post in this thread, perhaps the newsgroup can keep track each point you answer. so the more active you are on the newsgroup, the more points you can earn. and maybe at the end of the year you get a gift. some type of incentive for helping out the community.

 

oh and one more thing ... you mentioned how easy it is to search in this new forum ... well to date i dont think i've gotten the search function to work one single time.

 

what's the trick for searching for something on this site?

try it ... click the 'search' link in the nav bar above, and search for the word 'tab' ... surely SOMEONE in here has asked a question about setting up tabs in FusionPro! well if i search for 'tab', it comes up empty.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

oh and one more thing ... you mentioned how easy it is to search in this new forum ... well to date i dont think i've gotten the search function to work one single time.

 

what's the trick for searching for something on this site?

try it ... click the 'search' link in the nav bar above, and search for the word 'tab' ... surely SOMEONE in here has asked a question about setting up tabs in FusionPro! well if i search for 'tab', it comes up empty.

You've stumbled upon one of the most unpopular "features" of the vBulletin engine upon which this forum is built: searches with fewer than four characters (letters) simply do not work.

 

A search for "tab stop" does work. You can also use Google to search within the site, for example: "tab site:forums.printable.com".

 

We are looking into the issues with searching, along with automatic email notification, which we agree would be a valuable feature; you don't need to convince us further. As Mark noted, we're prioritizing our development time to work on the product itself.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I know this is coming to the party late, but I'd like to throw my hat in for support of the current forums (not that I think they are going away). I've been around the "interwebz" for a long time, and over the years I've developed nothing but contempt for mail lists. Two of the biggest problems with them is quote bloat (by the time you're in the 3rd message of a particular topic you have to scroll through about 300 lines of double-quoted text) and users not abiding by the "old ways" of using strictly plain text mail clients. Combine those two and you often end up with a 300 line message that is totally unreadable due to all the "%" and "=" that have been injected into it. The OOO problem is annoying as well, but that was already mentioned.

 

I use message boards such as this on several sites, a number of which aren't even work related, so I'm used to this format. You can subscribe to a thread to get real time notification if you like, but the real beauty of a message board is that it you don't have to use it in real time. I see it as more of a my time medium, and I appreciate that about it. My 2 cents.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...